Skip to main content

English Composition 112 (Wayne College): Evaluation Workshop: Evaluation Workshop Activities

Activity: Examining Popular and Scholarly Publications

In your group, examine the provided sample periodicals.  You should each have a sample of a popular magazine and a sample scholarly journal.  

Complete the "Comparing Popular and Scholarly Periodicals" worksheet, reflecting how your samples differ among the listed categories.

As a group discuss how using scholarly materials address the need for locating accurate and reliable information.

Activity: Looking at Audience to Determine Purpose

Each group will be provided sample issues of a popular magazine.  As a group complete the "Getting to the Core of A Popular Magazine: Looking at Audience to Determine Purpose and Potential Bias."

Report back to the class:

Who is the intended audience for this publication?

What potential research paper topics may be presented in a biased way in this publication?

Activity: Sample Magazine Covers

Let's examine a few sample magazine covers and look for visual clues for bias:

Ms. Magazine

Christianity Today

New American

Activity: Evaluate Some Sources

The librarian will divide the class into teams.  Each of the teams will be assigned sources to evaluate using the criteria in this guide. The entire class will be using the same research question listed below.

Each team will have difference sources provided by the librarian. Pretend that these sources were discovered after performing a thorough online search using recommended library research databases and search engines.

Your team will decide which team members will address each of the evaluation criteria by distributing the team's index cards.  Team members will refer to the appropriate tabs in this guide that correspond to their assigned criteria, and write notes on the card.

Once the team has evaluated their assigned source using the criteria, they will come to consensus on whether or not this source should be considered for this research question:

Research Question: Would allowing guns on campus make college safer?

Chat with Us!

Chat service is available during normal hours of operation.

chat loading...

Get the Chat App:

Download the Ask a Librarian Mobile App on your mobile devices. Search for "UA Wayne College Library" to chat with us.

Were we unavailable when you needed us?

Did you need help from the UA Wayne College Library staff and we were either closed or unavailable? Sorry we missed you!  Please complete this form to let us know what you needed so we can improve our services (including hours of operation).

Contact the Wayne College Library

Phone: 330.684.8789

Fax: 330.683.1381


SMS Text: 330.551.5275

Instant message / Chat

Staff Contacts

Maureen Lerch, Wayne College Library Director

Maureen Lerch's picture
Maureen Lerch
Wayne College Library
1901 Smucker Rd.
Orrville, OH 44667